We pulled our own Search Console data last week while checking a title change, and one pattern was hard to miss. Our article on Google's November 2024 core update earned around 120 impressions over the summer and not one click. A piece on ChatGPT's shopping features, similar story. Neither ranks on page one, so some of that is position. But the same shape shows up in accounts that do rank: impressions holding or rising, clicks sliding, because Google now answers the question itself in the box above the results and the reader leaves without visiting anyone.
That is AI Overviews doing exactly what they were built to do, and if you publish informational content, it is happening to you as well.
Which searches still send people
Overviews appear most on questions with a tidy answer. What is a core update, how long does SEO take, that sort of thing. If your content plan was built on those, the traffic is going and it is not coming back.
Clicks survive where the answer needs a person, a price or a decision. Comparing two specific products, or anything local, where the map pack and the business profile still sit right there on the page. Searches with commercial intent survive too, because Google still very much wants you to click an ad. And brand searches, which is why the strongest defence against all of this is being a company people look for by name.
What we are doing differently
We stopped writing the explainer. The "what is PPC" post that used to be a reliable traffic source is now a free answer for Google to lift, so that time goes on pieces that carry an opinion, a specific example or a number you cannot get elsewhere. This post is one of them. Our own zero-click data is more use to you than a generic paragraph about AI search would be.
We also write to be quoted. Overviews cite their sources and the cited links do get clicked, so a clear, direct sentence that answers the question in plain language near the top of the page has a chance of being the sentence Google uses. Structured data helps here too. We added FAQ schema to our services page this summer for exactly this reason.
And we changed what we report. Clicks alone now understate what a page is doing. A page that gets cited in an Overview builds familiarity with the brand even when nobody clicks, which shows up later as a brand search or a direct visit. So we look at impressions and average position alongside clicks, and we watch branded search volume as an outcome in its own right. We have also stopped promising clients traffic growth on informational content, because that promise stopped being honest a while ago.
SEO still works for the searches where a human has to make a choice at the end of them. If you want to know which of your pages are being answered away and which still earn a visit, we can pull the same Search Console view for your site that we pulled for ours. Twenty minutes, and it usually rewrites the content plan.
